Special thanks to Thank you, Dr. Raj Shah, of Koehler Instrument Company. Inc., and Nanotech Industrial Solutions CEO, Dr. George Diloyan for this article
Originally published in Nanotech Mag: Innovation in Nanoparticle Additives for Water-Based Lubricants
The use of mechanical systems and machinery is one of the cornerstones of a modern industrialized economy. Maintaining a long operation life with minimal wear and loss of performance is a crucial concern for any industry. Along with designing more efficient machines and mechanisms, lubrication is a core approach to addressing this concern. It is part of a field of research and industry of its own – tribology. By applying a lubricating agent, reduced wear and extended operation life can be achieved by minimizing friction forces on contact surfaces, and, as a result, reducing mechanical stresses on machine components and increasing operation efficiency . From engine oils to drilling fluids, lubrication agents like oils and greases remain a vital component of industrial processes with an estimated industry worth of $164.3 billion as of 2019. Experts project that by 2024, the lubricant industry, pushed by innovation and growing demand in the transportation industry and other industrial sectors, will grow to $188 billion .
One of the fundamental drivers for innovation within the lubricant industry in what could be considered as the “Third Industrial Revolution” and includes broad technological developments, such as the rise of electric vehicles, automation, and 3D printing, is the expanding application of nanotechnology . The nanotechnology market has grown from $26 billion in 2014 to $48.9 billion in 2017 and has applications in a variety of major industries ranging from pharmaceuticals to semiconductors to the lubricant industry [4,5]. Following the latest market trends of cost optimization, environmental friendliness, as well as higher reliability and performance, end-users expect improved tribological properties (anti-wear, anti-friction, extreme pressure protection, etc.) from modern lubricants. Today, nanotechnology is a leading method for achieving the desired properties in the form of nano-additives .
Nano-additives are designed to enhance the tribological performance of the lubricant by reducing friction (or the CoF, to be precise) and forming a protective layer(s) on the contacting surfaces. Such layers are called tribofilms; they are formed by chemical modification when friction forces arise during mechanical operation after physical and/or chemical adsorption of the tribologically active compounds onto the component surface . Protective layers of molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) are commonly sought after due to this material’s capacity of reducing CoF and is traditionally achieved through additives containing MoS2or molybdenum complexes containing sulfur compounds such as dithiocarbamate and phosphorodithioate [6,7]. Most of these compounds are difficult to synthesize and their production process involves toxic chemicals. It is a concern, especially when the market is leaning more towards eco-friendlier, sustainable, and scalable products. For example, the use of phosphorodithioates in motor oil applications may damage catalytic converters due to the presence of phosphorus.
Inorganic nanoparticles are a better alternative. They do not pose the same environmental and toxicity concerns during production as dithiocarbamates or phosphorodithioates and do not require a period of increased friction/heat to generate MxS2 (Mx – metal) tribofilms meaning they can reduce friction and protect surfaces with no startup time. Depending on their morphology and composition, specifically engineered inorganic nanoparticles may have multiple mechanisms to improve lubricant’s tribological behavior, such as the rolling effect, surface correction, and polishing [6,8]. Designing nanoparticles with a spherical morphology can induce a rolling effect similar to that of a ball bearing mechanism in which the spherical nanoparticles applied to the friction surface are capable of rolling in between the contacting surfaces during operation to reduce the coefficient of friction . The surface correction effect describes how the nanoparticle deposits part of itself to fill in asperities and surface irregularities while forming a protective microlayer. Lastly, the polishing effect refers to abrasive effects while under friction forces in which the nanoparticle physically smoothes out the friction surface [9,10]. Designing inorganic nanoparticle additives with these mechanisms in mind is indispensable to developing innovative lubricants that meet the increasing demands for the high-performing lubrication.
To take advantage of the tribological benefits of inorganic nanoparticles, they should be mixed with a proper base substance that together will form the lubricating agent. Their physical state can categorize these agents from solid and semi-solid to liquid and gas. Solid based lubricants include, but are not limited to, graphite, WS2, and MoS2 powders/coatings. Oil-based greases are a good example of a semi-solid lubricant. A liquid lubricant with typically 90 percent oil and up to 10 percent additives serves for reduced friction and wear, and resistance to corrosion whereas nitrogen and helium are the typical gaseous lubricants.
Liquid lubricants may also be composed of water as a base substance instead of oil, thereby resulting in a lubricant that takes advantage of water’s material abundance and is environmentally benign. However, there is a common perception that water-based lubricants heat up too fast and may lead to metal parts rusting. On the contrary, water will not burn like oil and will reduce the heat more effectively. Therefore, the properties of the water-based drilling or metalworking fluid depend on the additives. This is where inorganic nanoparticles may play a significant role thanks to their tribological properties. A water-based lubricant with specially designed inorganic nanoparticle additives would do away with the limited supply and environmental hazards of oil-based formulations while matching/exceeding its tribological performance and retaining the environmental safety and ease of handling of water. The lubricating properties of inorganic nanoparticles depend on their morphology and dispersibility in the liquid (in our case – solvent) rather than the viscosity of the solution itself, indicating its overall versatility and suitability for water-based lubricant applications .
Water-based lubricants formulated with inorganic nanoparticle additives have tremendous potential in improving the performance of a wide range of industrial lubricants, including fire-resistant fluids, drilling fluids, and metalworking fluids (MWF’s). MWF’s, in particular, are an excellent example of the net benefits that a water-based lubricant can have.
MWF’s can be separated into roughly three separate categories: synthetic, semisynthetic, and neat oil. Synthetic metalworking fluids are typically water-based substances that have cooling capabilities but little to no lubricity. Neat oil working fluids are highly lubricious but have limited cooling properties. Semi-Synthetic metalworking fluids are emulsions of water and oil that have both cooling capabilities and lubricity but are inferior to synthetic working fluids or neat oil fluids individually in those regards. Also, they are difficult to dispose of, usually toxic, and can be subject to degradation from bacteria . By incorporating specially designed inorganic nanoparticles into synthetic water-based metalworking fluids, high lubricity and excellent cooling capabilities could be achieved simultaneously while avoiding the drawbacks of semi-synthetic and neat oil metalworking fluids. The abundant availability and environmentally benign nature of water, multiplied by a tremendous effort that has been put into the synthesis of inorganic nanoparticles for water-based lubricants, translates into a significant opportunity for lubricant manufacturers.
For water-based lubricant applications, numerous nanoparticle shapes and compositions have been investigated and are commercially available. Liu Y H, et al characterized the performance of graphene oxide and diamond nanoparticles noting a sharp decrease of the COF of Si3N4 sliding against of Al2O3 from 0.6 to as low as 0.01 after 250s while H. Wu et al. found a decrease of 0.5 to 0.25 and significant wear reduction from TiO2 nanoparticles in a 0.8% wt solution with water [8,12]. Among commercially available options, inorganic fullerene-like tungsten disulfide (IF-WS2) nanoparticles such as those produced by Nanotech Industrial Solutions (NIS) are promising due to excellent tribological capabilities resulting from their spherical shape, lamellar structure, and submicron size. The spherical fullerene-like shape allows for the rolling effect mechanism of lowering the coefficient of friction and serves to impart high elasticity to withstand extreme pressures (EP) while preventing micro-cracks and pitting. Simultaneously, its submicron size (20-280 nm) allows for the surface correction effect by filling in asperities thereby smoothing the friction surface and preventing crack propagation. Investigations into the performance of IF-WS2 additives in water-based lubricant formulations at different concentrations in comparison to other lubricants were conducted on samples prepared as described in Figure 2 below.
Fig. 2) Table of samples prepared for investigation of IF-WS2 water-based MWF’s
When tested against Group II base oil lubricant SN150, IF-WS2 water-based lubricants were found to withstand up to 1,000 Kgf of Weld load depending on the percent composition in water compared to the 126 Kgf of SN150 under Four-Ball EP testing conditions as specified by ASTM D2783 . Compared to samples of commercial emulsions and semisynthetic fluids, samples incorporating IF-WS2 particles were found to withstand more than double the load under the same testing conditions as shown in Fig. 3. In addition, these nanoparticles can exfoliate under friction loads to Impart a single or multi-layer tribofilm onto the friction surface providing additional protection thereby enhancing wear reduction and lowering the COF as load increases as can be shown by the progressively lower COF values from 600N to 1200N on the Stribeck Curve of Sample 5 in Fig. 4 .
Fig. 3) Four ball EP performance of water, SN150 oil, IF-WS2 water-based lubricants, and commercial emulsion/semi-synthetic lubricants (samples 6 and 7)
Fig. 5) Stribeck Curve of Sample 5 indicating lower friction as load increases
When compared with samples of commercially available emulsion/semisynthetic fluid lubricants, IF-WS2water-based lubricants exhibited lower CoF values and reduced wear as indicated in Figure 6. Application of IF-WS2 water-based lubricant reduced COF down to approximately 0.09 with no significant “break-in” CoF compared to commercial emulsions/semi-synthetic lubricants (samples 6 and 7) when testing in accordance to ASTM G99 under 1000N load and angular velocity of 0.3 m/s. The combination of reduced CoF and application of a protective tribofilm translated into reduced wear values of 1.1 mm for the Ball on disc wear test (ASTM G99 under 1000N) and 1.13 for the Four-ball wear test (ASTM D4172), for sample 4 of IF-WS2 water-based lubricant. This matched the performance of commercial emulsion lubricant (sample 6) for the Ball on disc wear tests and exceeded both commercial emulsion and semisynthetic lubricants (samples 6 and 7). In comparison to the reported values of TiO2 and graphene oxide, the IF-WS2nanoparticles exhibited lower minimum CoF than TiO2 (COF of 0.5 to 0.25) and higher than graphene oxide (0.6 to 0.01), but with much lower initial CoF as shown by the CoF curves of samples 2, 3, and 4 starting with a CoF of 0.12 down to around 0.09 indicating superior lubricity. In addition, a combination of a concentrate of 4% commercial emulsion and 0.54% IF-WS2 concentrate resulting in a water-based lubricant with 0.27% IF-WS2 by weight represented by sample 5 showed the lowest ball on disc wear of 0.97mm and second-lowest 4 ball wear of 1.15mm while having the lowest COF of approximately 0.08. In nearly all cases, the water-based lubricants incorporating IF-WS2 nanoparticles showed smaller wear and a lower COF while being capable of operating under higher pressures in comparison to traditional oil-based lubricants. In addition, less tribologically active material (0.27% IF-WS2 vs 6% of commercial emulsion/semi-synthetic lubricant) is required indicating excellent efficiency and opportunities for lower net machining and process costs .
Fig. 6) Tribological performance tests of IF-WS2 water-based lubricant against commercial emulsion/semisynthetic MWF’s [11,13]
To test this potential application, 4% conventional emulsion-based lubricant and 0.54% IF-WS2 concentrate were used to synthesize a sample of 0.27% IF-WS2 water-based lubricant that was compared against a 6% in H2O commercially available semisynthetic MWF. A field trial was performed utilizing both lubricants to lubricate a carbide tip tool operating under high speed while temperature, noise levels, and lubricity were measured. The IF-WS2 water-based lubricant was found to have lowered operating temperatures by 80%, improved lubricity by 34%, and lowered noise levels by 4.9% in comparison to the commercially available lubricant as depicted in Fig. 7 .
Fig. 7) Summary of field trial comparison of 0.27% IF-WS2 water-based lubricant against commercially available semisynthetic MWF. Carbide tip toolbar: SS304 stainless steel, Diameter: 2in., Length: 12in., Feed: 0.01in.
When applied to commercially available multitool systems such as the Nakamura NTY3 over a period of 24 days, tribological improvements on a single tool scale translated to nearly double the parts produced and the elimination of an entire maintenance cycle as shown in Fig. 8 .
Fig. 8) Parts Production comparison between conventional coolant vs IF-WS2 water based coolant on operation of Nakamura NTY3 over 24 days. Part production increased from 6279 up to 11370 pcs. Maintenance cycles decreased from 3 down to 2 when using the IF-WS2 water based coolant.
By incorporating IF-WS2 nanoparticles into synthetic metalworking fluids, this water-based lubricant can perform under high loads and high temperatures while simultaneously possessing the environmentally sustainable and ease of disposal characteristics of water. When tested on commercial machining tools, the superior lubricity, cooling, and operating characteristics of IF-WS2 nanoparticles translated into nearly 100 percent improvement in part production capacity; IF-WS2 nanoparticles also helped eliminate at least one of the usual three maintenance cycles. As a result, NIS has taken a particular interest in incorporating IF-WS2 nanoparticles into water-based lubricants, and other companies within the industry are taking similar approaches. FUCHs has focused on developing a research project VisionFluid FETM . The main goal is to design a superior water-based lubricant for automotive applications with a new, extremely low level of friction on the “superlubricity” range, below 0.01 CoF . Whether it may be through IF-WS2 nanoparticles or some other nano-sized additive entirely, lubricant manufacturers, such as NIS and FUCHs, will continue to rely on nanotechnology in water-based lubrication to meet the performance and environmental demands of the future.
Dr. Raj Shah is an elected fellow of RSC, InstMC , AIC, STLE, NLGI, IChemE, CMI, and El. He is a Chartered Petroleum Engineer from the Energy Institute, a chartered chemical engineer from Institution of Chemical Engineers, a Fellow member of the Chartered Management Institute, London, an eminent engineer with Tau beta pi engineering honor society and a Chartered scientist from the science council. Currently, he is a Director at Koehler Instrument Company located in Long Island, NY where he has been for 25 years. Contact: email@example.com
Mr. John Calderon is part of a thriving internship program at Koehler Instrument company in Holtsville, and a student of Chemical Engineering at Stony brook university, Long island, where Dr. Shah is the current chair of the external advisory board of directors.
Dr. George Diloyan is CEO of NIS Inc. He holds a PhD in Mechanical Engineering from Temple University with a focus on nanotechnology, electrochemistry and material science as well as two MS degrees in Physics and Computer science. He has extensive experience with applications of nanomaterials to solve hardcore industrial problems, knowledge of particle agglomeration, and degradation mechanisms.